Understanding Pay Transparency
The concept of “pay transparency" has been making headlines recently. Ten U.S. states and six municipalities have already implemented some form of pay transparency laws, with 14 additional states and the federal government considering similar regulations. You can check out the current pay transparency laws on payscale.com.
What has sparked the recent surge in increased regulations for pay transparency? This blog post aims to simplify what pay transparency means and why startup and small business owners should pay attention to this growing trend.
Pay Transparency Defined
Pay transparency is the practice of openly sharing information about an organization’s compensation structure. It involves making details about salary ranges, salary structures, and the factors influencing pay decisions accessible to all applicants and employees. This approach aims to create a culture of openness, equity, and fairness in compensation practices.
Pay Transparency History
The idea of pay equity has been around since the 1860s, advocating for "Equal Pay for Equal Work," and has since continued to be a highly inequitable employment factor. Pay has traditionally been a taboo topic not openly discussed amongst employees. However, increased attention has grow on this issue due to pay inequities, especially affecting women and people of color. With changing workplace dynamics, laws now protect employees who openly discuss their pay to mitigate these inequities.
According to the American Association of University Women, women face pay disparities, earning $0.82 for every $1 a man is paid. The disparities are even more pronounced for women of color; Latina, Native American, Black, and Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander women earn an average of $0.63 for every $1 a white man is paid, while Asian women earn $0.99.
Several factors contribute to these inequities:
Lower Paying Jobs: Women tend to occupy more lower paying jobs with fewer benefits such as cashier, administrative assistant, and childcare worker roles.
Childbearing Years: Women are more likely to leave the workforce during their childbearing years, placing them at a disadvantage for discrimination in career progression.
Family Responsibilities: Women are more likely to seek positions that allow more flexibility to handle family responsibilities, such as reduced schedules or refraining from working on weekends or evenings.
Elder Caregiving: Women are more likely to assume caregiving responsibilities for elder parents, leaving them with less time to earn more.
Bias in Leadership: Women face bias in terms of selection for leadership positions, despite ranking more highly than men in top leadership qualities, according to a Harvard Business Review study.
Suggested Reading
Why Pay Transparency Matters
Promotes Equity & Accountability: Pay transparency identifies and rectifies any existing pay gaps and holds organizations accountable for fair compensation. It ensures that employees are compensated fairly for their skills, experience, and contributions, fostering a more equitable workplace.
Motivates Performance: Employees are motivated to perform their best when they know that their efforts will be recognized and rewarded. Pay transparency eliminates the mystery around compensation allowing employees to link performance to rewards (pay-for-performance culture) such as more compensation or a promotion.
Enhances Recruitment: Pay transparency can be a powerful recruitment tool as it showcases your commitment to fairness and openness and makes your company more attractive to work for. Job applicants are 68% more likely to apply for a job posting that is transparent about pay. Pay transparency eliminates the compensation “game” that causes frustration in candidates during the interview process.
Builds Trust and Retention: Transparent pay practices build trust among employees. When team members have a clear understanding of how compensation is determined, they are more likely to feel valued and motivated and less likely to feel jealous or resentful. This leads to better team collaboration and engagement. Additionally, employees are more likely to stay with a company where they feel their compensation is justly determined.
Ways to Implement Pay Transparency in Small Businesses
The truth is that pay transparency is here to stay and avoiding hiring employees in states or municipalities that have pay transparency laws is not a sustainable strategy. Legal experts foresee pay transparency for employers to soon be a federal law. Here’s what your business can do:
Implement a Pay Transparency Policy: Before creating a pay transparency policy, ensure you have a performance review/evaluation policy; we recommend combining these policies. Your Pay Transparency Policy should outline the following factors:
No adverse action (discipline, termination, retaliation, etc.) against employees for discussing their pay.
Require a salary range to be posted on all job postings.
Define the process for merit increases and the direct link to job performance, commonly known as “pay-for-performance.”
Describe the steps taken to monitor adherence to the policy such as audits.
Outline the process for determining pay increases due to promotions.
Provide employees information about how performance affects pay and other factors considered, such as experience, skills, and market demand for specific roles.
Salary Ranges and Job Requirements: Distinctly define salary ranges for each job role within your small business. See our blog post about how to create a simple compensation plan. A job description for each job role in your business should be created to accurately define requirements for education, experience, and skills. Then, ensure job descriptions are audited at least annually and make any adjustments.
Communication Strategy: Linking performance metrics to compensation and openly communicating this connection helps employees understand how their individual contributions impact their pay. If your business has current employees, make any necessary pay adjustments based on the new salary ranges and job performance, then communicate the changes to the employees.
Regular Compensation Reviews: Conduct reviews of your compensation practices at least every other year to ensure alignment with market trends and internal equity. Share the overarching outcomes of these reviews with employees to reinforce your commitment to fair pay.
Educational Initiatives: Educate employees about your performance and pay transparency policies and how compensation decisions are made. You can conduct this training in a variety of forums to include Q&A sessions, webinars, or office hours; CPR recommends a verbal setting versus a written form such as email. Provide employees information about how performance affects pay and other factors considered, such as experience, skills, and market demand for specific roles. If employees understand the policy, it will help mitigate the volume of employee questions.
Bottom Line
Pay transparency is not just a passing trend; it's becoming a fundamental aspect of the modern workplace. Embracing it from the start can create a culture of trust, fairness, and motivation within your small business. Before implementing pay transparency, consider your company culture and make changes that align with your business’ values. For personalized guidance, consult with CPR – Your HR Ally!
Disclaimer: The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only. Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal or other information.
